Spiritualism
Spiritualism is a religious movement that began in the United States and Britain in the nineteenth century, based on the belief that the individual survives death, continues to progress in a spirit world, and can communicate with the living, usually through a medium. It is conventionally dated from the "rappings" heard by the Fox sisters at Hydesville, New York, on 31 March 1848, though its ideas were already circulating before that date.
Spiritualism has no single creed for the informal movement as a whole. For about half a century it flourished without canonical texts or a formal organisation, held together by periodicals, touring trance lecturers, séances and summer camp meetings. Formal organisations came late: the National Spiritualist Association of Churches (NSAC) was founded in the United States in 1893, and the Spiritualists' National Union (SNU) in Britain in 1901.
Beliefs and practices
Spiritualists believe that a person's awareness persists after death, that the afterlife — the "spirit world" — is not a static place but one in which spirits continue to interact and develop, and that the living can contact the dead. Communication is usually through a medium, a person believed to be able to contact spirits directly, often while in a trance. Some mediums are said to work with a particular "spirit guide", a spirit relied on for guidance.
A formal session of communication is a séance, usually held in a darkened room around a table. Other practices associated with the movement include:
- Table-turning: participants rest their hands on a table, which tips, rocks or raps out letters. The craze swept Paris in April 1853; the physicist Michael Faraday showed in 1853 that unconscious muscular action could move a table, a finding believers disputed as a complete explanation.
- Trance mediumship and trance lecturing: the medium speaks or lectures, apparently in trance, attributing the words to a spirit. This was central to Andrew Jackson Davis, Cora L. V. Scott and Emma Hardinge Britten.
- Spirit photography: photographs said to show the spirits of the dead alongside the living. The first prominent practitioner was William H. Mumler of Boston, from 1861. Sceptics attributed the extra figures to double exposure and pre-exposed plates; Mumler was tried for fraud in New York in 1869 and acquitted.
- Slate writing: messages said to be written by spirits on slates held under a table or in the medium's lap.
- Trumpet mediumship and direct voice: spirit voices said to be heard through a trumpet, or directly, without the medium speaking.
- Physical mediumship and ectoplasm: a pale substance said to be exuded from the medium's body during trance, from which spirit forms were said to be built. Samples examined by investigators were identified as gauze, muslin, egg white or chewed paper; believers disputed that finding.
- Spiritual healing: healing by mediums, including trance healing and laying-on of hands, advertised at camps including Lake Pleasant. Healing is codified in the NSAC's ninth principle.
Spiritualists also generally hold that a person's condition after death is related to the morality of their earthly life, and that moral responsibility, rather than a final judgment or hell, governs progress in the spirit world.
Spiritualism, Spiritism and Theosophy
Spiritualism is often confused with two related movements. They are distinct:
- Spiritism is the doctrine codified by the French educator Allan Kardec (born Hippolyte Léon Denizard Rivail, 1804–1869). His first foundational text, The Spirits' Book, appeared in 1857. Spiritism is book-based and codified, and its distinguishing tenet is that spiritual progress comes through a series of compulsory reincarnations. Anglo-American Spiritualism, by contrast, was for decades uncodified and centred on the séance, and traditionally did not require belief in reincarnation. The reincarnation question split American organisations — notably at Lake Pleasant in 1913.
- Theosophy was founded by Helena Petrovna Blavatsky (1831–1891), who co-founded the Theosophical Society in New York on 17 November 1875. Blavatsky came out of Spiritualist circles and held séances herself, but rejected the claim that séance entities were souls of the dead, holding them to be lower astral entities, and promoted reincarnation and karma and the idea of hidden wisdom. Theosophy claimed to offer knowledge rather than mere contact with the dead.
Origins
Andrew Jackson Davis
The movement's intellectual precursor was Andrew Jackson Davis (1826–1910), the "Poughkeepsie Seer". A shoemaker's apprentice turned mesmeric trance clairvoyant, Davis dictated The Principles of Nature, Her Divine Revelations, and a Voice to Mankind in 157 trance lectures between 28 November 1845 and 25 January 1847; it was published in 1847, a year before Hydesville. His system, Harmonial Philosophy, described the afterlife as the "Summer Land", a series of progressive spheres, and rejected hell, final judgment and an anthropomorphic God. He is often credited with predicting Spiritualism.
The Fox sisters and Hydesville
On the night of Friday 31 March 1848, in a house at Hydesville, Wayne County, New York, the Fox family heard raps and knocks that seemed to answer the children's clapping and questions by numbers of raps. The two younger sisters were Margaretta ("Maggie") Fox (1833–1893) and Catherine ("Kate") Fox (born about 1836–1892; sources differ on the year). The questioners identified the supposed spirit as a peddler said to have been murdered in the house and buried in the cellar.
The family left the house and the girls went to live with their older sister, (Ann) Leah Fox Fish (1814–1890), in Rochester. Public demonstrations in Rochester drew hundreds of people, and the sisters moved to New York City in 1850, holding lucrative séances. The practice of sitting for communication with spirits spread rapidly in the 1850s in the United States, Britain and France.
On 21 October 1888, Margaret Fox confessed at the New York Academy of Music that the rappings had been a hoax, produced by cracking her toe and foot joints, and demonstrated the method on stage. She later retracted the confession; the date and form of the retraction are not consistently given in the sources. The confession is often cited as a turning point, but Spiritualism continued to grow for decades afterwards.
Key figures
- Andrew Jackson Davis (1826–1910) — see above; The Great Harmonia (1850–52), A Stellar Key to the Summer Land (1867).
- The Fox sisters — Margaret, Kate and Leah; see above.
- Emma Hardinge Britten (1823–1899) — English-born medium, trance lecturer and historian of the movement. She moved to New York in 1855, wrote Modern American Spiritualism (1870) and Nineteenth Century Miracles (1884), campaigned for abolition, women's rights and marriage reform, and was a frequent speaker at Lake Pleasant. Her summary of faith became the basis of the SNU's Seven Principles.
- Victoria Woodhull (1838–1927) — Spiritualist medium and faith healer, stockbroker, newspaper publisher and suffragist. She was the first woman to run for President of the United States, nominated by the Equal Rights Party on 10 May 1872, with Frederick Douglass as her running mate (he did not accept). She was 33, below the constitutional age of 35, her name did not appear on ballots, and she received no electoral votes.
- Cora L. V. Scott, later Richmond (1840–1923) — the best-known American trance lecturer, who began falling into trances at age 11 or 12 and gave thousands of lectures in the United States and England. She presented Spiritualism at the Parliament of the World's Religions in Chicago in 1893, co-founded the National Spiritualist Association that year, and was its first vice-president.
- William Stainton Moses (1839–1892) — English Anglican clergyman turned medium; his automatic writing of 1872–1883 was published as Spirit Teachings (1883), sometimes called the "Bible of British Spiritualism". He helped found the London Spiritualist Alliance and edited its journal Light.
- Daniel Dunglas Home (1833–1886) — the most celebrated physical medium of the Victorian era, said to levitate, handle hot coals and play an accordion untouched. He was investigated by the physicist Sir William Crookes in 1871, who reported phenomena he could not explain by imposture under his conditions. Home refused payment for sittings and was never caught in fraud during his career, though later witnesses claimed foot-tricks.
- Eusapia Palladino (1854–1918) — Italian physical medium investigated from the Milan sittings of 1892 by Charles Richet, Cesare Lombroso, Pierre and Marie Curie and others. She was repeatedly caught cheating, and herself admitted occasional trickery when phenomena failed; researchers remained divided about her.
- Leonora Piper (1857–1950) — Boston trance medium, the most investigated medium in history. William James began investigating her in 1885 and called her his "one white crow" — a single case that could disprove a universal claim. He later attributed her successes to telepathy or cold reading rather than spirit contact.
- Arthur Conan Doyle (1859–1930) — creator of Sherlock Holmes and the world's best-known advocate of Spiritualism. He declared his belief publicly in 1916 and in public speaking in 1917, before his son's death — a common retelling reverses the order. His son Kingsley, wounded at the Somme in 1916, died of pneumonia on 28 October 1918. Doyle wrote The New Revelation (1918), The Vital Message (1919), The Coming of the Fairies (1922) and the two-volume The History of Spiritualism (1926), and toured Britain, Australia, South Africa and the United States lecturing.
- Harry Houdini (1874–1926) — escape artist who in his last years campaigned against fraudulent mediums, calling Spiritualism "a fraud from start to finish" in Congressional testimony in 1926, in support of a bill to criminalise fortune-telling for hire in Washington, D.C. He and Conan Doyle had been friends; the friendship broke over a séance in which Doyle's wife Jean, as medium, purported to deliver a message from Houdini's dead mother, which Houdini regarded as a ruse. Houdini died on 31 October 1926.
Investigation, fraud and debunking
From the start, Spiritualism was investigated by scientists, stage magicians and commissions, and repeatedly damaged by fraud exposures. Whether any medium genuinely communicated with the dead remains disputed and unproven by scientific consensus; every rigorously tested case was either exposed as fraud or given a natural explanation by sceptical investigators, while believers and some psychical researchers maintained that genuine cases existed. Both sides should be kept in view.
- The Seybert Commission (1884–1887): a University of Pennsylvania faculty commission, funded by a $60,000 bequest in the will of Philadelphia Spiritualist Henry Seybert (died 1883). It began investigations in March 1884, examining slate-writing (Mrs S. E. Patterson, no result under scrutiny; Dr Henry Slade, caught in fraud), spirit rappings (Margaret Fox Kane, November 1884), physical mediumship, spirit photography, materialisation and direct voice. Its Preliminary Report (May 1887) found fraud or suspected fraud in every case examined, and described slate writing as performed "in a manner so closely resembling fraud as to be indistinguishable from it". No final report was ever published. Spiritualists angrily denounced the report.
- The Society for Psychical Research was founded in London in 1882 by Henry Sidgwick, Frederic W. H. Myers (who coined "telepathy") and Edmund Gurney, as the institutional home of much of this investigation.
- The Scientific American contest (1922): the magazine offered a $5,000 prize for scientific proof of spirit communication, on Conan Doyle's suggestion. The judging committee included two scientists, two psychic researchers and Houdini. The most famous candidate was the Boston medium Mina Crandon, known as "Margery", whom Houdini investigated and exposed. Whether the prize was ever awarded was not established from the sources consulted.
- Houdini's crusade: see above. His 1926 Congressional testimony and his public exposures of mediums' methods were a major blow to the movement's public standing.
Organisations and doctrine
National Spiritualist Association of Churches
The National Spiritualist Association of the United States of America was founded at a three-day convention in Chicago, Illinois, on 27 September 1893; its first president was Harrison D. Barrett, a resident of Lily Dale, New York. Leading founders included Barrett, James M. Peebles and Cora L. V. Richmond. Its purpose was to bring order to a chaotic, decentralised movement and to answer fraud charges. It was later renamed the National Spiritualist Association of Churches (NSAC), and its headquarters are now at Lily Dale. It defines Spiritualism as "the Science, Philosophy, and Religion of continuous life, based upon the demonstrated fact of communication, by means of mediumship, with those who live in the Spirit World".
Its Declaration of Principles, in nine points, is the movement's best-known statement of doctrine. Paraphrased, the principles affirm: (1) an Infinite Intelligence; (2) that the phenomena of nature, physical and spiritual, express that intelligence; (3) that true religion is understanding that expression and living by it; (4) that the individual and their personal identity continue after death; (5) that communication with the dead is a fact, scientifically proven by the phenomena of Spiritualism; (6) that the highest morality is the Golden Rule, "Do unto others as you would have them do unto you"; (7) personal moral responsibility, and that people make their own happiness or unhappiness by obeying or disobeying nature's physical and spiritual laws; (8) that the doorway to reformation is never closed to any soul, here or hereafter; and (9) that prophecy and healing are divine attributes proven through mediumship. Principles 1–6 were adopted in Chicago in 1899, principles 7–8 in Rochester, New York, in 1909, and principle 9 in St. Louis, Missouri, in 1944 (one secondary source dates it to 1945). The full verbatim text is on the NSAC's own site.
Counted NSAC membership was always far smaller than the movement's claimed following: 258 churches and 11,266 members in 1936; 280 churches and 12,000 members in 1946; 204 churches and 5,000 members in 1970; 144 member congregations in 2002. No reliable current total was found.
Spiritualists' National Union
The Spiritualists' National Union (SNU) was founded in the United Kingdom on 18 October 1901, growing out of the Spiritualists' National Federation organised at Manchester on 1 April 1891. Its motto is Light, Nature, Truth. Its Seven Principles, drawn from Emma Hardinge Britten's summary of faith, are: the Fatherhood of God; the Brotherhood of Man; the Communion of Spirits and the Ministry of Angels; the Continuous Existence of the Human Soul; Personal Responsibility; Compensation and Retribution Hereafter for All the Good and Evil Deeds Done on Earth; and Eternal Progress Open to Every Human Soul. They are presented as a moral and ethical framework, not binding dogma.